Comcast's Reported Roku and ViacomCBS Merger Plans Doused in Cold Water By Analysts

Comcast headquarters
(Image credit: Comcast)

Media analysts threw ice-cold water on a Wall Street Journal report Wednesday suggesting that Comcast may buy ViacomCBS and/or Roku

"From a regulatory standpoint, ViacomCBS is a non-starter with network/station overlaps, even before considering whether network/content production market share would be an issue," Credit Suisse's Douglas Mitchelson wrote in a note to investors Thursday morning. 

As for Roku, the analyst believes the Silicon Valley streaming company's $56 billion-plus market cap makes acquisition of it cost-prohibitive. 

"Acquiring Roku would be highly dilutive and likely lever Comcast's balance sheet (something that management has been clear it will not do near-to-mid term), in pursuit of a new out-of-market connected TV strategy with unclear longer-term barriers to entry and customer acquisition costs, and which management has already been building internally," Mitchelson said. 

Meanwhile, Bank of America analyst Jessica Reif Ehrlich said Comcast's so-called PlatCo initiative, in which it's working with Walmart and Hisense to make smart TVs powered by a Comcast OS, is in competition with Roku. 

"We believe a Roku acquisition would be duplicative with [Comcast's] own Flex hardware and would add nothing from a content/IP perspective," Ehrlich said in a morning investor report. 

Comcast is reportedly in the process of evaluating bold M&A moves as it tries to bolster the position of Peacock in the ultra-competitive video streaming race. 

In a Thursday research note, Barclays media analyst Kannan Venkateshwar wrote that outside the obvious regulatory obstacles to additional M&A for Comcast, he remains skeptical that Comcast would consider buying ViacomCBS or Roku.

It’s only been a few weeks since Comcast chairman and CEO Brian Roberts and chief financial officer Michael Cavanagh were making the rounds at virtual industry conferences telling analysts and investors that there was no desire for a big deal. So doing a big deal, according to the analyst, would be a blow against Comcast’s credibility. 

Still, Venkateshwar said it was difficult to dismiss Comcast’s M&A intentions, given its deal-making track record. Although a Roku deal could give the company a streaming advantage when coupled with its NBCUniversal and Peacock assets, he believed it would be better to build than buy.  

Given Roku’s $56 billion market cap, Venkateshwar said it would make more sense for Comcast to give out free Flex devices to every household in its Comcast/Sky footprint.

“Comcast also has the choice of spending more money on Peacock and making that a free, ad-supported service, which would make it potentially bigger than the Roku Channel, especially given Comcast’s own footprint,” Venkateshwar added.

Wells Fargo media analyst Steven Cahall noted that Comcast’s past M&A endeavors have resulted in a big dip in its stock price, which should be catalyst enough to discourage any buying spree.  

Also Read: Warner Bros. Discovery is No Streaming Powerhouse Yet, Analyst Says 

In a Thursday report, Cahall wrote Comcast stock dropped about 23% between January 2018 and June 2018, the period it was in a bidding war with Disney for the Fox assets. 

“We think investors have just regained confidence that an uninterrupted buyback period is coming, and this confidence will now be shaken,” Cahall wrote. “Given other Media consolidation (e.g. Discovery/WarnerMedia, Amazon/MGM) we think it will be tough to lay M&A fears to rest short of levering up for a buyback.” 

Daniel Frankel

Daniel Frankel is the managing editor of Next TV, an internet publishing vertical focused on the business of video streaming. A Los Angeles-based writer and editor who has covered the media and technology industries for more than two decades, Daniel has worked on staff for publications including E! Online, Electronic Media, Mediaweek, Variety, paidContent and GigaOm. You can start living a healthier life with greater wealth and prosperity by following Daniel on Twitter today!

Latest in Business
DirecTV and Dish
Next Text: As DirecTV and Dish Try to Seize the Remains of the Day, Does It Even Matter?
Paramount
Paramount Starts New Round of U.S. Staff Reductions
Comcast Janus Facility
Comcast Unveils New Edge Cloud Network-Management System
Roku Ultra Player + Voice Remote
Roku Touts Refresh for Its 'Ultra' Streaming Gadget
USC vs. Michigan
Next Text: If You Like Football, You've Once Again Got to Pay $100 a Month For TV
Utah Hockey Club
NHL's New Utah Hockey Club Launches DTC Streaming App With Kiswe
Latest in News
Dish and DirecTV satellite dishes
DirecTV Acquires Dish, Unifying Struggling Satellite Business
B+C Hall of Fame class of 2024
Freeze Frame: B+C Hall of Fame 2024
DirecTV and Dish
Next Text: As DirecTV and Dish Try to Seize the Remains of the Day, Does It Even Matter?
Adam Symson speaks to KNXV Phoenix GM/VP Anita Hecht.
E.W. Scripps Folding Scripps News, Eliminating 200 Jobs; Stock Jumps 15%
Sabrina Ionescu #20 of the New York Liberty handles the ball during the game against the Las Vegas Aces on September 8, 2024
WNBA Playoffs Continue: What’s On This Weekend in TV Sports (Sept. 28-29)
Fubo Multiview
Fubo Launches 'Multiview' Beta on Roku